Virginia, DC, and Maryland Personal Injury Attorney News

Disability Insurance Claims

• How Should A Judge Assess Disability?
  Sep 19, 2008

  - 71 - 80

• Another Court takes MetLife to Task for its disability reviews
  Sep 18, 2008

  Here is news of yet another court overturning a MetLife disability case based on "independent" reviews. Wright v. Raytheon. - 72 - 80

• Court takes Prudential Insurance Company to task in disability claim.
  Mar 24, 2008

  Graham Harrison, suffered from Tourette Syndrome which prevented him from working on a full time basis.  He applied for partial disability benefits under a disability insurance policy his employer had with Prudential Insurance Company of America.  His treating physician, a neurologist and specialist in Tourette Syndrome had recommended that he consider reducing his work schedule to less than full time to accommodate his condition which have led to chronic anxiety, a disrupted sleep pattern and agitation.  His doctor felt that a four day work week with a mid week break would benefit him immensely.
  
  Prudential denied the request for benefits.  Prudential's position was that since he had suffered Tourette's Syndrome for many years his records did not document a significant recent change that would warrant a change in his work patterns.  Prudential also felt that if he could work four days there was no reason that he could not work five days in a week.
  
  At first Prudential relied on the opinion of its "medical director", Jill C. Fallon, M.D., a doctor who was Board Certified in occupational medicine but had absolutely no expertise in neurology or Tourette's Syndrome.  This doctor did not even examine the claimant.
  
  Prudential also looked at the wrong definition of disability in denying the claim.
  
  Mr. Harrison appealed the denial of benefits and included additional reports from his well qualified physicians.  On appeal, Prudential showed the file this time to Albert Kowalski, M.D. another one of its employed physicians.  Not only did Dr. Kowalski not have Board Certifications in neurology or psychiatry, he had absolutely no experience in the treatment of Tourette Syndrome and indeed had not had any clinical practice since 1987.  Dr. Kowalski did not examine the claimant.  Despite the lack of qualifications and any current experience in actually seeing patients, Dr. Kowalski was of the opinion that the claimant's condition should have improved over time.
  
  On the basis of Dr. Kowalski's opinion, Prudential denied the claim.  In denying the appeal Prudential once again quoted the wrong definition of disability.  The plaintiff again appealed and this time consulted with yet another expert in Tourette Syndrome.  He was evaluated by Oliver Sacks, M.D. a clinical professor of neurology at Albert Einstein College of Medicine and an adjunct professor of neurology at the New York University School of Medicine.  Dr. Sacks had authored numerous books and articles on Tourette Syndrome.  It was Dr. Sacks' opinion that Mr. Harrison could maintain his effort and function very effectively for only two days at a time and then must take a break of a day to recover.  He cannot function on a "standard" five day week.  On the basis of this letter Prudential reversed its original decision and awarded benefits to the plaintiff.  Prudential however continued to misstate policy provisions and indeed quoted language that appeared nowhere in the plan.
  
  Two months after approving the claim Prudential began re evaluating the claim.  This time Prudential took the position that the plaintiff's disability was caused at least in part by a mental psychoneurotic or personality disorder and that benefits were limited to 24 months.  Prudential advised the claimant that his claim would most likely terminate the next month.
  
  The problem with Prudential's denial of benefits this time was that there was no 24 month limitation in this policy.
  
  Prudential also referred the file to Stephen N. Gerson, M.D.  Dr. Gerson was Board Certified in psychiatry and geriatric psychiatry but listed his major professional activity as "administration."  There was no evidence in the file that Dr. Gerson had any experience in the treatment of Tourette's Syndrome.  He did not examine the claimant.  It was Dr. Gerson's opinion that the various treating physicians and the claimant himself were simply making a "preference" for not working a five day work week.  Shortly thereafter Prudential terminated benefits yet again.
  
  Mr. Harrison filed suit under ERISA.
  
  The court reversed Prudential's denial.  The court found that "In the worst light, such conduct [misquoting policy provisions] indicates a conscious attempt on the part of Prudential to manufacture a reason for denying plaintiff benefits."
  
  The court also found that the decision to terminate benefits was not supported by substantial evidence.  The court said that Prudential had ceased on one piece of information that one of the doctor's had relayed to it to terminate benefits.  The court found that Prudential had not relied on any new information to terminate benefits after it had previously approved benefits on the same information.  The court also was critical of Prudential for using doctors who had no expertise in Tourette Syndrome and who never examined the claimant.
  
  Fairfax, Virginia attorney Ben Glass represents doctor, dentists, lawyers and business executive in long term disability benefit claims.
  
  - 73 - 80

Free Books

• Allstate Pays Dearly for Drunk Driver Who Caused Virginia Accident
  Dec 13, 2009

  Even though their driver was drunk and almost thrown in jail by a judge, Allstate insurance Co. did not think this case had much value at first. Thanks to great work by smart attorneys, Allstate increased its initial offer offer over four times. Virginia car accident victims can draw their own conclusions about whether they should hire an attorney to prosecute a claim against Allstate insurance Company.
  
  Here is the report on the Virginia drunk driving personal injury settlement.
  
  - 74 - 80

• State Bar Shuts Down Local Bankrupty Attorney
  Oct 01, 2009

  Yet another attorney shut down for improper practices. I wonder how many other lawyers out there practice in a similar manner and are able to slide by. Here's a link to the Anne Miller story.
  
  The lesson to take from this is to know about who you're hiring before you hire them. Read my book The Truth About Lawyer Advertising - 75 - 80

• Another Sad Story of a Lawyer Disbarred for Stealing
  Sep 30, 2009

  A Grundy, Virginia lawywer has had his license revoked for stealing.
  
  This is a shame.
  
  Here is the link to the breaking story. Good for the Virginia State Bar for nailing the guy.
  
  
  
  - 76 - 80

Accident Cases

• BenGlassLaw April 2010 Personal Injury Newsletter
  Apr 18, 2010

  her driver’s license for only a few months started to drive away from the drive-in window where she had picked up her Big Mac order. She stomped on the accelerator too hard, panicked and tried to slam on the brakes, but succeeded only in hitting the accelerator even harder.
  
  Read more about this case of insurance company frivolous defense and fraud here.
  
  - 77 - 80

• Woman Who Abused Legal System Will Have Time to Think About Her Crimes
  Oct 06, 2009

  Please don't ever think you can get away with staging fake accidents in Virginia. First, the insurace companies are pretty smart and do all they can to diminish legitimate claims.
  
  But fake an accident?
  
  Then put your kids in the car and tell them to pretend they are injured.
  
  There are some real sleazy characters in this world.
  
  This woman will spend years in a federal penitentiary (somewhere, apparently, that she is somewhat familiar with already.) - 78 - 80

• Honda Expert Caught Destroying Evidence!
  Nov 08, 2005

  TV screenwriters could not have written a more sordid tale of corporate malfeasance. Here's the story of how one judge stood up to a major corporation, and then how Trial Lawyers for Public Justice fought to have an order unsealed which exposed this expert witness. - 79 - 80

• Virginia Verdicts
  Aug 14, 2005

  What Virginia Juries say about injury cases. - 80 - 80





Contact Ben Glass Privately

Remember, we set up this "send Ben Glass an email" form for your convenience. This form does not make you a client of BenGlassLaw. Ben is licensed in Virginia and the District of Columbia only. While we'll keep what you tell us secret, remember that we can only give specific legal advice once you become a client of the firm. This is done written agreement only.

First Name *

Last Name *

Phone *

Email *

Your Message




Please enter the Security Code shown below

Testimonials

• Congratulations on having been selected by your peers for inclusion in the 2011 edition of The Best Lawyers in America®
  
• This is our first experience meeting with a lawyer. Surprisingly, our meeting with Ben went so well. It was very informative and educational.
• We were deeply touched by your kindness.
• I contacted Attorney Ben Glass's office and franticly spoke to his assistant Terry. We had a little more than two weeks to challenge my LTD provider's threat to offset my LTD disability payments by the amount of a recent settlement I had received on a Worker's Compensation claim - the claim was settled outside of the Worker's Compensation system.
• I want to thank you and your staff for all your hard work in 2009. I greatly appreciate your efforts on my wife's disability appeal. Your staff worked hard, is very talented and your ethical approach was readily apparent.
  
  Stephen Power
  
  

View All